25 Best Horror Games of All Time That Define the Genre

25 Best Horror Games of All Time lists are always a little dangerous, because horror isn’t “one size fits all.” Some people want pure survival panic, others want psychological dread, and a few of you are monsters who play with headphones in the dark on purpose.

So this list is built around impact. Games that shaped the genre, defined sub-genres, or still feel scary even when you know the trick. To keep it grounded, we cross-checked consensus picks from major outlets and community discussion, then layered in modern standouts and a few “new blood” picks that already have a serious case for future classic status.

And yes, we’re also including new and upcoming horror games that have the potential to crash the party, because the genre’s best eras usually happen when something fresh shows up and ruins everyone’s sleep schedule.

25 Best Horror Games of All Time: How This List Was Picked

Horror is subjective, but “all-time” needs some standards. This list prioritizes games that hit at least one of these:

• Genre-defining influence (it changed what horror games look like)
  
• Still-scary design (tension systems, audio, pacing, vulnerability)
  
• Cultural staying power (people still recommend it constantly)
  
• Modern relevance (newer titles that already sit in the same tier)

See Also: The Game Awards 2025 Breaking Down The Biggest Moments

25 Best Horror Games of All Time

Silent Hill 2

The benchmark for psychological horror. Silent Hill 2 replaces cheap scares with grief, guilt, and symbolism, creating an atmosphere that feels deeply personal and deeply uncomfortable even decades later.

Resident Evil 2 (Original & Remake)

A survival horror masterclass. Both versions deliver relentless tension through smart enemy placement, limited resources, and an environment that constantly pressures the player forward.

Alien: Isolation

One of the most effective horror AIs ever created. The Xenomorph adapts to player behavior, turning every mistake into a potential death sentence and making fear feel earned.

Dead Space

Industrial sci-fi horror done right. Dead Space’s dismemberment mechanics, oppressive sound design, and claustrophobic corridors make every encounter stressful and memorable.

Resident Evil 4

A genre-shifting title that blended action and horror without losing tension. Its influence on camera design, pacing, and combat is still felt across modern games.

Amnesia: The Dark Descent

The game that redefined modern horror vulnerability. With no combat and sanity as a mechanic, fear comes from helplessness rather than firepower.

Amnesia: The Bunker

A bold evolution of the formula. Semi-open levels, dynamic systems, and resource pressure make every decision feel dangerous and irreversible.

Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly

A slow-burn nightmare rooted in folklore. Using a camera as a weapon creates a uniquely intimate and unsettling relationship with its ghosts.

Outlast

Pure survival panic. Armed with nothing but a camera, Outlast’s relentless pacing and first-person perspective helped define an entire era of horror content.

SOMA

Existential horror at its finest. SOMA’s true terror lies in its questions about identity, consciousness, and what it means to be human.

Alan Wake 2

A modern horror statement piece. Blending psychological horror, experimental storytelling, and live-action elements, it’s confident, strange, and deeply unsettling.

P.T.

Short, cancelled, and legendary. P.T. proved that subtle environmental changes and repetition could be more terrifying than any monster.

Signalis

Retro-inspired survival horror with cosmic dread. Its minimalist presentation hides a deeply emotional and disturbing narrative beneath the surface.

Resident Evil 7: Biohazard

A franchise rebirth through fear. First-person perspective and tight environments brought Resident Evil back to its survival horror roots.

Resident Evil Village

More action-driven, but still unforgettable. Its shifting horror styles and iconic sections cement it as one of the series’ most memorable entries.

See Also: Skate Story Drops Day One on PS Plus: All Details Explained

Little Nightmares

Childhood fears turned into surreal horror. Its scale, silence, and grotesque character design make it quietly disturbing.

Little Nightmares II

Bigger, darker, and emotionally heavier. The sequel expands the world while doubling down on psychological unease.

The Last of Us

Horror-adjacent, but essential. Its infected encounters, brutal tone, and emotional weight create sustained dread throughout the journey.

Phasmophobia

Unscripted fear at its best. Its ghost systems and voice recognition mechanics make every session unpredictable and tense.

Silent Hill 2 Remake

A rare example of modernization done carefully. It preserves the original’s psychological core while updating presentation for a new generation.

Silent Hill: Townfall (Upcoming)

A new psychological entry backed by Annapurna Interactive. With its creative team and franchise legacy, Townfall has serious future-classic potential.

Little Nightmares III (Upcoming)

The continuation of a modern horror staple. With co-op elements and a broader world, it’s poised to expand the franchise’s influence.

Directive 8020 (Upcoming)

Sci-fi survival horror from Supermassive Games. Shapeshifting threats and space isolation make it one of the most promising upcoming horror projects.

Clive Barker’s Hellraiser: Revival (Upcoming)

A narrative-driven survival horror built around one of horror’s most iconic IPs. Clive Barker’s direct involvement gives it strong legacy potential.

Ontos (Upcoming)

From the creators of SOMA, Ontos aims to deliver another existential horror experience. Early reveals suggest heavy atmosphere and philosophical dread.

Horror Games That Didn’t Make the List (But Almost Did)

Putting together the 25 Best Horror Games of All Time means leaving out some excellent titles that still deserve recognition. These games narrowly missed the cut due to scope, longevity, or overall genre impact. But definitely not quality.

• Visage
• Madison
• Darkwood
• Condemned: Criminal Origins
• Until Dawn

See Also: PlayStation’s 2025 Wrap-Up: A Deep Dive Into Your Stats

The 25 Best Horror Games of All Time aren’t defined by graphics or jump scares. Rather they’re defined by how long they stay with you. These are the games that linger in memory, shape the genre, and continue to influence what horror becomes next.

Ready to build your horror backlog or grab a few classics on sale? Top up Steam Gift Cards on Joytify and dive into the games that never let you feel safe.